Journal of
Fisheries and
Aquatic Science
ISSN 1816-4927
www.academicjournals.com
OPEN ACCESS
Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science
ISSN 1816-4927
DOI: 10.3923/jfas.2018.39.48
Research Article
Reproductive Biology of the Threatened Menoda Catfish,
Hemibagrus menoda (Hamilton, 1822) in the Kangsha River,
Bangladesh
1,3
Ibrahim Shehu Jega, 1M. Idris Miah, 1Nahida Arfin Huda, 1M. Atiqur Rahman, 1Mst. Kaniz Fatema,
M. Mahfujul Haque and 1M. Shahjahan
2
1
Department of Fisheries Management, Bangladesh Agricultural University, 2202 Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Department of Aquaculture, Bangladesh Agricultural University, 2202 Mymensingh, Bangladesh
3
Department of Forestry and Fisheries, Kebbi State University of Science and Technology, Aliero, Nigeria
2
Abstract
Background and Objective: Knowledge of reproductive biology of a fish species is particularly important for conservation and plays
significant role in determining its sustainable management and suitability for culture. Aspects of reproductive biology of Hemibagrus
menoda from Kangsha River Netrakona district, Bangladesh were studied to evaluate the on-set and period of spawning season and its
reproductive potential, which were hitherto not reported. Materials and Methods: A total of 479 females and 400 males were collected
using Gill nets and Seine nets from March, 2015 to February, 2016. Gonadosomatic index (GSI), fecundity and histology of the gonads were
investigated. Regression analysis was used to estimate the relationships between fecundity and standard length (SL), fecundity and body
weight (BW) and fecundity and ovary weight (OW). Results: The monthly mean GSI of female H. menoda started to increase from
May to June and reached the peak (12.50±4.97) in July, indicating the peak spawning season of the fish. Mean fecundity
estimates based on mature females was 77273.77±276.82 for fishes with mean length of 31.85±2.39 cm and ranged from
22954.99; 25.00 (cm) in May to 222171.8; 40.20 (cm) in July. Fecundity correlated positively with SL (Log F = 0.0135+4.399 log SL;
r2 = 0.774), BW (F = 198.7 BW-47602; r2 = 0.805) and OW (F = 1066 OW+6124; r2 = 0.832). Based on histological data, yolk vesicle,
premature and mature stages of oocytes were abundant in May, June and July, which further confirms the distinct spawning season of
H. menoda from May to July. Conclusion: Hemibagrus menoda spawns once a year and the spawning season extends from May to July
with a peak in July. This reproductive pattern helps in development of culture program and conservation of the species.
Key words: Reproductive biology, GSI, fecundity, gonadal histology, spawning season
Citation: Ibrahim Shehu Jega, M. Idris Miah, Nahida Arfin Huda, M. Atiqur Rahman, Mst. Kaniz Fatema, M. Mahfujul Haque and M. Shahjahan, 2018.
Reproductive biology of the threatened menoda catfish, Hemibagrus menoda (Hamilton, 1822) in the Kangsha river, Bangladesh. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci.,
13: 39-48.
Corresponding Author: Ibrahim Shehu Jega, Department of Fisheries Management, Bangladesh Agricultural University, 2202 Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Tel: +8801757480423, +2348039370546
Copyright: © 2018 Ibrahim Shehu Jega et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the creative commons attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing Interest: The authors have declared that no competing interest exists.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its supporting information files.
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
of broodstock and ultimately increasing the fish production11.
INTRODUCTION
Several studies have been conducted on various aspects of
Fish reproductive biology is important in stock
reproductive biology of fishes including sex ratio12-14, GSI15-17,
assessment, fishery resource management, fisheries research
fecundity18-20 and histology of the gonads21-23. Not until
and
profitable
aquaculture
practices.
Knowledge
recently, Jega et al. 24, studies on the reproductive biology of
of
the menoda catfish were hitherto not reported. In this regard,
reproductive parameters such as sex ratio, onset and duration
the purpose of this study was to provide the first hand
of spawning season, maturity stages, ova diameter, fecundity
information on some aspects of reproductive biology such as
and histology of the gonads are particularly important for
the GSI, fecundity and histology of the gonads of H. menoda
conservation of fish species . Hemibagrus menoda, one of
1,2
from the Kangsha River, Bangladesh, so as to lay foundation
the ray-finned, iteroparous and gonochoristic fishes, is among
for the induced breeding, culture and eventual domestication
the 8 species in the genus Hemibagrus belonging to the
of this threatened fish species.
family Bagridae. The species is characterized by having dark,
vertical spots on its abdomen and is found in the river
MATERIALS AND METHODS
drainages in Bangladesh and northern India3. However,
Hossain reported that due to natural and anthropogenic
4
induced changes, H. menoda have become critically
Sampling site: Samples of H. menoda were monthly collected
endangered. Moreover, the IUCN categorized the fish as near
from the Kangsha River located at Jaria-Jhanjail, Latitude
threatened.
25E0'41.10"N and Longitude 9E0 38'27.16"E in the Netrakona
5
district, Bangladesh.
Spawning season refers to that part of the year in which
various fish species get sexually active for spawning6. The
expulsion of gametes from the body into the surrounding
Sample collection: A total of 879 samples, including 479
water
is called ʻspawningʼ, resulting in fertilization.
females and 400 males were collected from the landing sites
Knowledge of spawning activity is gaining more importance
from March, 2015 to February, 2016. The specimens were
as restoration efforts on large rivers to benefit endangered
identified according to Rahman25 and Hossain26 and sexed
species and fish diversity requires specific knowledge of when
according to Norton et al.27. Fishing gears used in catching the
fishes reproduce and the coincidence of environmental
fish include Gill net, Seine net and by angling. The freshly
conditions7. Spawning season can be determined by studying
landed fishes were immediately iced at the sampling site,
gonadosomatic index (GSI) of the species, external features of
transported to the Aquaculture Laboratory of Bangladesh
the ovaries, such as size and by histology of the gonads. The
Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh, where the
GSI is often used to follow the reproductive cycle of a species
experiment was conducted. The Total length (TL) of the
over the year at monthly or less intervals and is a good
specimens ranged from 31.55-45.37 and 35.48-43.43 cm for
indicator of gonadal development of fish8. The GSI assumes
females and males, respectively.
that an ovary increases in size with increasing development by
comparing the mass of the gonad with the total mass of the
Gonad collection: The ventral side of the fish was cut and
fish. Information on fecundity is also important in order to
opened from the anus towards the lower jaw by using scissors
evaluate a fish for its commercial potentials and to develop
and the whole mass (fat tissues, stomach, liver, ovary, liver,
numerical relationship between egg production and
etc.) were removed and the gonads carefully detached from
recruitment9,10. Moreover, to bring a new species in
the other visceral organs by the use of needles and forceps.
aquaculture, information of reproductive biology is essential
The gonads were then cleaned with tap water and wiped with
in case of mass seed production for supporting commercial
blotting paper. The ovary weight (OW) was then taken before
being kept in 10% buffered formalin (40% formaldehyde;
Lab Grade-37% w/v) for study of fecundity and GSI.
aquaculture in Bangladesh, a 5th leading aquaculture
producing country in the world. Study of these parameters is
necessary in order to arrive at some conclusions on the
maturity and breeding season of this species which will aid in
Determination of GSI: To determine the sexual maturity, the
its propagation. Histological studies are the most reliable
female GSI was calculated using the formula:
technique to assess the reproductive strategy and tactics of
fish species and also to determine peak period of spawning
GSI
and to understand effective methods for increasing efficiency
40
Gonad weight (GW)
100
Body weight (BW)
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
Fecundity estimation: Fecundity of H. menoda was
into one cassette and labeled with a pencil accordingly.
Standard histological processes involving dehydration,
clearing, infiltration, embedding, trimming and blocking,
sectioning, staining, mounting and observation of slides
under a light microscope (XSZ-PW107) for identification of
gametogenic cell types were performed.
estimated for 169 matured females following the gravimetric
method according to Nandikeshwari et al.28, Akter et al.29 and
Islam et al.30. The external connective tissues were removed
from the surface of the ovaries and blotting paper used to
remove moisture from the surface of the ovaries. A sub sample
of about 1-2 mm and 0.20 mg of the gonad was cut from the
anterior, middle and posterior parts of the ovary and
separately put in a Petri dish. The eggs were separated by
using needle and forceps and counted with the aid of
magnifying glass. Care was taken to sort the mature and
immature eggs. The total number of matured and immature
eggs of each ovary sub sample was sorted out and counted
with the help of a needle and magnifying glass and estimated
using the equation:
F1
Statistical analyses: Mean GSI values of the female samples
were computed monthly. Regression analysis was performed
using MS Excel 2007 to estimate the relationships between
fecundity and standard length, fecundity and body weight
and fecundity and ovary weight.
RESULTS
Morphology of the gonads: Macroscopic examination of
H. menoda during the 12 months study period showed that
Gonad weight
Number of eggs in subsample
Sub sample weight
the gonads in female and male are bilobed, located in the
dorsal portion of the body cavity, separated into two equal
sizes, joined each other at the caudal region and formed a
common duct at the base of uro-genital papillae. Ovaries in
the developing and immature H. menoda are pinkish, slender
and translucent and resemble immature testes in appearance.
As they advance in maturity, they become pale green and
greenish in colour and expand in length and diameter. Testes
are thin, ribbon-like and somewhat segregated in developing
(immature) fish but as the fish progress in maturity, they
become creamier, whitish and serrated.
By taking the mean number of three sub sample
fecundities (F1+F2+F3), the absolute (total) fecundity FT, for
each female fish was then determined using the formula
as19:
FT
F1 F2 F3
3
Relative fecundity determination: Relative fecundity is the
number of eggs per unit length or weight of individual fish
and was calculated as 31:
GSI: The mean values of GSI ranged from 0.00±0.00
(December) to 12.50±4.97 (July) in female which showed
distinct seasonal changes. The GSI started increasing in May,
reached the peak in July and then abruptly dropped in August.
Consequently, the GSI remained very low throughout the
study period. The monthly variations in the mean GSI of
female H. menoda is shown in Fig. 1.
Relative
Absolute fecundity
fecundity (Fr)
Standard length or fish body weight or ovar y weight
Estimation of fecundity-length and weight relationships:
Relationships between absolute fecundity and standard
length (SL), body weight (BW) and ovary weight (OW) were
determined using the formulae32: F = a SLb, F = a+b BW and
F = a+b OW, respectively, where ʻaʼ represents the intercept of
the regression with y-axis and ʻ bʼ the slope of the regression
line.
Fecundity: The mean fecundity was 77273.77±276.82 for
Histological examination of oocytes: Ovaries belonging to a
fishes with mean SL of 31.85±2.39 cm and mean BW of
628.37±18.60 g (Table 1). The highest fecundity (222171.8)
was in July from fishes with mean SL and BW of 40.20 cm and
1074.00 g, respectively. The lowest (22954.99) was in May from
fishes with mean SL and BW 25.00 cm and 389.00 g,
respectively.
range of developmental stages were prepared for histological
study by fixing in 10% buffered formalin for 3 days. They were
then taken out from vials and cross sections from different
parts cut and placed on tissue paper so as to absorb the
moisture. Each cross section of an ovary was separately put
terms of SL, BW and OW is presented in Table 2-4, respectively.
Slight fluctuation was observed in the relative fecundity in
terms of SL. However, lowest (903.47) relative fecundity was
Relative fecundity: The relative fecundity of H. menoda in
41
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
Mean GSI
15
10
5
0
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
J
F
Month
Fig. 1: Monthly variation in the mean GSI of female H. menoda
The vertical bars indicate standard deviation
Table 1: Egg counts of H. menoda collected from Kangsha River Netrakona Bangladesh (March, 2015-February, 2017)
Month
May
May
May
June
June
July
July
July
Mean±SE
Range
Fish No.
SL (cm)
BW (g)
OW (g)
GSI
Absolute fecundity
10
09
10
21
20
34
29
36
31.50
25.00
33.40
28.50
26.70
40.20
29.50
40.00
31.85±2.3
25.00-40.2
665.00
389.00
478.00
400.00
336.00
1074.00
437.00
1248.00
628.37±18.6
336.00-1248.00
9.00
5.54
17.05
37.20
17.30
88.60
78.50
141.00
49.27±0.97
5.54-141.00
1.35
1.42
3.57
9.30
5.15
8.25
17.96
11.30
7.29±2.3
1.35-17.96
35869.59
22954.99
39869.59
70295.76
24025.37
222171.80
30821.26
172181.80
77273.77±276.8
22954.99-222171.8
SL: Standard length, BW: Body weight, OW: Ovary weight
Table 2: Relative fecundity of H. menoda in relation to standard length (SL)
Number of fish examined
40
19
19
24
28
39
Mean±SE
Range
Size group (SL, cm)
Absolute fecundity
Relative fecundity (SL, cm)
25.00-27.00
27.01-29.00
29.01-31.00
31.01-33.00
33.01-35.00
>35.01
31.85±2.39
25.00-40.20
23490.18
70295.76
30821.26
35869.59
39869.59
197176.8
66253.86±257.14
23490.18-197176.8
903.47
2510.11
1027.20
1120.75
1172.46
5633.62
2061.27±42.97
903.47-5633.62
Size group (BW, g)
Absolute fecundity
Relative fecundity (BW, g)
330.00-380.00
381.00-430.00
431.00-480.00
>481.00
468.25±0.89
356.00-1248
24025.37
46625.37
35345.43
143407.73
62350.97±58.56
24025.37-143407.7
67.677
114.980
77.590
298.140
139.60±2.37
67.67-298.16
Table 3: Relative fecundity of H. menoda in relation to body weight (BW)
Number of fish examined
38
37
37
57
Mean±SE
Range
Table 4: Relative fecundity of H. menoda in relation to ovary weight (OW)
Number of fish examined
Size group (OW, g)
Absolute fecundity
Relative fecundity (OW, g)
38
37
37
57
Mean±SE
Range
5.00-35.00
35.01-75.00
75.00-105.00
>105.01
49.27±1.26
5.53-141
28417.44
70295.76
126496.53
172181.80
99347.88±125.52
28417.44-172181.8
1420.87
1278.10
1405.51
1638.26
1435.69±6.11
1278.10-1638.27
observed in BW related fecundity (Table 3). Lowest (67.677)
relative fecundity was recorded in the lowest
(330.00-380.00 g) size group fishes while the highest (298.14)
observed in smallest (25.00-27.00 cm) size group fishes while
highest relative fecundity was enumerated in the largest
(>35.01 cm) size group (Table 2). Deviations were also
42
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
250000
200000
Fecundity
Log F = 0.0135+4.399 log SL (r2 = 0.774)
F = 0.013SL4.399
2
r = 0.774
Where:
F
= Fecundity
SL = Standard length
150000
100000
50000
The estimated coefficient of determination was 0.774
suggesting that 77.4% of the variation in fecundity was due to
variation in SL. The slope (4.399) which is greater than 3 in the
equation indicated that fecundity increases as the fish gets
longer.
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
Standard length (cm)
Fig. 2: Correlation between fecundity and standard length of
Hemibagrus menoda
250000
200000
Fecundity
Fecundity-BW relationships: The logarithmic relationship
F = 198.7BW-47602
2
r = 0.805
between fecundity and BW of H. menoda gave a linear
equation: F = 198.7 BW-47602; r2 = 0.805 (Fig. 3). The
coefficient of determination showed that 80.5% variation in
fecundity was due to variation in BW. A straight line through
the origin would fit the points well which told that the number
of eggs were directly proportional to the weight of the fish.
150000
100000
50000
0
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
Body weight (g)
Fecundity-OW relationships: In order to study this
relationship, the fecundity values were plotted against the
respective weight of ovaries as a scatter diagram (Fig. 4).
Strong coefficient of determination (r2 = 0.832) was found
between OW (X) and fecundity (Y). The relationship between
fecundity and OW may be expressed using regression
equation as:
Fig. 3: Correlation between fecundity and body weight of
Hemibagrus menoda
200000
Y = 1066x+6124
2
r = 0.832
Fecundity
150000
100000
F = 1066 OW+6124; r2 = 0.832
50000
and in logarithmic form as:
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
Log F = 1011+1.020 log OW (r2 = 0.832)
Ovary weight (g)
Fig. 4: Correlation between fecundity and ovary weight of
Where:
F
= Fecundity
OW = Weight of ovary
H. menoda
relative fecundity was in the largest (>481) size group. Results
in Table 4 indicated that relative fecundity of H. menoda was
less dependent on OW. The lowest (1278.10) relative fecundity
in terms of OW was in the size group (35.01-75.00 g) while the
highest (1638.26) fecundity was in the size group ($105.01 g).
Variations in the histological features of H. menoda: The
development stages of the oocytes in female H. menoda
during oogenesis were identified over the 12 month study
period (Fig. 5). Microscopic observations of the different ovary
sections examined revealed different stages of development
such as undeveloped oocytes (UO), early perinucleolar stage
(EPNO), late perinucleolar stage (LPNO), cortical alveolar
stage (CA), yolk vesicle stage (YV), early yolk granule stage
(EYG), late yolk granule stage (LYG), pre-mature stage (PM)
and the mature stage (M) (Fig 5). The UO and EPNO were
observed in January and March samples and were
found to be minute in size and difficult to recognize.
Fecundity-length relationships: The relationship between
fecundity and SL for H. menoda is presented in Fig. 2. The
logarithm transformed fecundity and SL values were plotted
in the scatter diagram and yielded a non linear (power curve)
equation: F = 0.0135SL4.39. The logarithmic transformation
gives a linear regression (straight line regression) of fecundity
and SL of the fish as:
43
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f )
(g)
(h)
(i)
Fig. 5(a-i): Haematoxylin-eosin stained sections showing different developmental stages in ovary of H. menoda at 10x
magnification sampled in (a) March, 2016, (b) April, 2016, (c) May, 2016, (d) June, 2016, (e) July, 2016, (f) August, 2016,
(g) October, 2016, (h) December, 2016, (i) January, 2017. UO: Undeveloped oocytes, EPNO: Early perinucleolar oocytes,
LPNO: Late perinucleolar oocytes, CA: Cortical alveolar stage, YV: Yolk vesicle stage, EYG: Early yolk granule stage,
LYG: Late yolk granule stage, PM: Pre-mature stage and M: Mature stages
yolk granules appeared deep pink with haematoxylin and
eosin (June and July). At the end of mature (M) stage,
vitellogenesis was completed, oocyte full-grown and yolk
globules size increased (about 1060 µm). In the postvitellogenic oocytes large lipid vacuoles and yolk granules of
the remaining oocytes degenerated and underwent atresia
(August). Undeveloped oocytes (oogonia) predominate in the
later stages (October) of oocytes development characterized
by stem cells occurring singly. Subsequently the appearance
of CA (December) which stained deeply with haematoxylin
and eosin indicated the early stages of secondary growth
development.
The oocytes at this stage are often referred to as oogonia
and after staining with haematoxylin-eosin, their sizes
ranged from 17-54 µm. Oocytes in the mature stage were
found to contain 4 bands of oocytes, LPNO, YV, LYG and M
oocytes which predominates the May, June, July and August
samples. The YV stage signals the onset of the
vitellogenesis and initially appeared colourless on staining
with haematoxylin and eosin. The YV stage contains several
nucleoli which developed as minute bodies and
progressively became enlarged in diameter of the oocytes
(60-75 µm). At the LYG stage, oocytes increased
concurrently with the advancement of yolk granules and the
44
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
11.5-14.0 cm for Mystus dibrugarensis, which is lower than
that of H. menoda. Lower range was also reported by
Karmakar
and
Biswas18
for
Tetraodon cutcutia
(Pisces: Tetraodontidae) from Meleng River in Jorhat district,
Assam with minimum fecundity of 447.48 (TL = 5.86±1.19 cm)
and maximum fecundity of 1540.08 (TL = 6.55±1.36 cm).
Recently, lower minimum and maximum fecundity of 2230
(TL = 4.7-5.6 cm) and 8450 (TL = 7.7-8.6 cm) were recorded in
Perthia ticto in the study of Gorai River19. Fecundity within a
stock varies annually, undergoes long-term changes and has
been shown to be proportional to fish size and condition21,39.
Within a given species, fecundity may vary as a result of
different adaptations to environmental habitats40. The mean
fecundity of H. menoda was 77273.77±276.82 for fishes with
mean length of 31.85±2.39 cm. This mean fecundity of
H. menoda obtained in this study was higher than those
obtained for Alburnoides sp., Perthia ticto and Securicula gora
with average fecundity of 1722.92 (TL = 98.72 mm), 2586±700
and 23,860.12±4980.21, respectively31,41,42. It could be inferred
that H. menoda is a highly fecund fish.
Relative fecundity also contains information useful for
comparing the reproductive strategies in fish and could be
provided in terms of body and ovary weight2, 43. In this study,
though highest relative fecundity was found in fishes
belonging to the largest size group in terms of body weight
and ovary weight, some fluctuations exist as it was observed
that relative fecundity was not strictly dependent on body and
ovary weight of H. menoda. The relative fecundity of 77.59
oocytes was found in 431.00-480.00 body weight group which
is lower than the 114.98 oocytes found in the 381.00-430.00
weight group. Similar trend was found in relative fecundity in
terms of ovary weight of H. menoda. Khan et al.37 reported
57.664 ova per ovary weight in Plotosus canius with
average weight of ovary 21.287 g which was higher than the
14.022 ova per weight of ovary in a fish with ovary weight of
160.460 g. Therefore, this data somewhat conflicts the theory
that relative fecundity is ovary weight dependent but
corroborates with the theory that fecundity is affected by
species, age, feeding, season and environmental conditions44.
Fecundity in fishes is often correlated with length, body
weight of fish and also with weight of ovary45. In this study it
was found that fecundity increased with SL, BW and OW.
Moreover, it was also found that in H. menoda, OW (r2 = 0.832)
and BW (r2 = 0.805) are more responsible to increase in
fecundity than SL (r2 = 0.774). Similar results have been
reported for freshwater fishes Puntius stigma and
Monopterus cuchia and concluded that the correlation of
fecundity with gonad weight is more significant compared to
that of fecundity with other body parameters46,47. Results from
DISCUSSION
The reproductive biology of H. menoda in terms of onset
and duration of spawning through GSI, fecundity and
histology of the gonads were studied as important inputs in
the assessment and management of the fish stock. The GSI is
often used to identify the gonadal maturity and spawning
season of fish species. Examination of the ovary of H. menoda
revealed a distinct relationship between GSI and gonad
maturation in the fish. The high values of GSI in May, June and
July obtained in this study indicates the spawning season of
H. menoda. The highest value obtained only in July indicates
one peak spawning season. The onset of spawning season in
May observed for H. menoda coincides with the onset of rainy
season in the region. It could be inferred that maturation of
the gonads were influenced by the rainy season. This
corroborates with Kiran15 that the GSI of gonads of cyprinid
fish Salmostoma untrahi increased at rainy season whereas,
lowest GSI was in winter. Recently, similar results were
obtained in Labeo bata where high GSI values were observed
from May to August and only one GSI peak in the month of
June33. High GSI was recorded for Pomadasys jubelini in July
to September34. The findings of this study agree with Al
Mahmoud et al.35 who recorded higher GSI for Channa striata
from March to July with a peak in July. Siddiquee et al.16
reported similar results in Channa marulius from Sylhet basin
whereby highest GSI was obtained in July. Similarly Gupta and
Banerjee36 stated that GSI in female Mystus tengara reached
peak once a year during the month of July. Khan et al.37
mentioned that mature Plotosus canius (Grey-eel or Brackish
water catfish) became available from April to August, the peak
being July. Contrary to our findings, GSI of silver grunt,
Pomadasys argenteus was highest in March and an additional
small peak in October in the females38. The breeding period
(GSI) of female Oreochromis niloticus exhibited several peaks
in March, April, June and September21 suggesting that females
breed more than once a season (partial spawning), which is
contrary to our findings. Findings from this study showed that
H. menoda is a single spawner and the breeding season
expands from May-July with July being the peak.
Fecundity estimation of fishes is vital to having
information on the spawning season, reproduction potential
and seed production capacity of the species concerned.
In the present study, the minimum fecundity was 22,954.99
(SL = 25.00 cm) while the maximum fecundity was 222,171.8
(SL = 40.20 cm). Thus, the fecundity increased with increase in
length of H. menoda. Bailung and Biswas20 reported minimum
fecundity of 6,965±889.38 in fish of 6.5-9.0 cm and maximum
fecundity of 12,338.57±1241.04 in length group of
45
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
this study agree with Agarwal45 in his study of fecundity of
Schzothorax plagiostomus that a close correlation is usually
expected between number of eggs and ovarian weight and
volume.
From the foregoing, it is evident that H. menoda is a
highly fecund fish and its reproductive potential is quite high
in comparison to other fishes probably due its large size and
feeding habit as well as food productivity, temperature,
salinity and genetic difference of the stock.
Histological features of oocyte development stages were
also studied to ascertain the breeding season of H. menoda.
Histological observation revealed one spawning season in
H. menoda, from late April to July, which corresponds to the
monsoon season. In this study, oocytes maturation stages
were classified into undeveloped oocytes (UO), perinucleolar
oocytes (PNO), cortical alveolar stage (CA), yolk vesicle stage
(YV), yolk granule stage (YG), premature (PM) and mature (M)
stage. Al Mahmoud et al.35 and Milton et al.23 used similar
classification for Channa striata and Channa gachua,
respectively. In fish ovary, the premature (PM), yolk granule
(YG) and mature (M) oocytes are generally observed at the
most advanced stage of ovary when the fishes are ready for
spawning. In this study, YG, PM and M oocyte stages were
abundant from late April to July samples of ovary, indicating
the spawning season of H. menoda. The occurrence of M stage
oocytes was highest in July, indicating the peak breeding
season. Current findings are similar to Erkmen and Kirankaya22
who observed that mature oocytes in Mirror Carp and Scaled
Carp (Cyprinus carpio L., 1758) were first observed from the
beginning of April until July that corresponds with monthly
changes observed in GSI. The findings from GSI are in
concurrence with the histological observations, further
confirming the peak breeding season of H. menoda in July.
Undeveloped oocytes (UO), EPNO and LPNO stage oocytes
were abundant in October to January samples, indicating
spent stage of ovary of H. menoda.
SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT
This study discovered that H. menoda is a highly fecund
fish and provides the first information on the spawning season
(from May to July) of this species. In view of the recurrent
flood, excessive rains and water pollution that leads to
devastation of habitat and biodiversity in the Kangsha River
Netrakona which has inadvertently led to the population
decline of many economic species including H. menoda, this
study can be of immense benefit to conservationists and
aquaculturists in planning future management strategies as
well as breeding and culture program for this fish species.
Based on this discovery, a new cultured fish may soon be in
the market.
REFERENCES
1.
Shamsan, E.F. and Z.A. Ansari, 2010. Studies on the
reproductive biology of indian sand whiting Sillago sihama
(forsskal). Indian J. Mar. Sci., 39: 280-284.
2.
Tsikliras, A.C., K.I. Stergiou and R. Froese, 2013. Editorial note
on reproductive biology of fishes. Acta Ichthyol. Piscatoria,
43: 1-5.
3.
Ng, H.H. and C.J. Ferraris, 2000. A review of the genus
Hemibagrus in southern Asia, with descriptions of two new
species. Proc. California Acad. Sci, 52: 125-142.
4.
Hossain, M.A.R., 2014. Habitat and Fish Diversity: Bangladesh
Perspective. In: Advances in Fisheries Research in Bangladesh,
Wahab, M.A., M.S. Shah, M.A.R. Hossain, B.K. Baman and
M.E. Hoq (Eds.). Fisheries Research Forum, Dhaka, Bangladesh,
ISBN: 978-984-33-6729-7, pp: 1-26.
5.
IUCN., 2015. Red list of Bangladesh: A brief on assessment
result 2015. IUCN International Union for Conservation of
Nature, Bangladesh Country office, Dhaka, Bangladesh,
pp: 1-24.
6.
Haque, M.M., 2012. Fishes and Aquaculture Dictionary.
1st
CONCLUSION
Edn.,
Department
Agricultural
of
University,
Aquaculture,
Mymensingh,
Bangladesh
Bangladesh,
ISBN: 978-984-33-5829-5, pp: 25.
The GSI revealed that H. menoda spawns once a year and
the spawning season extends from May to July with the peak
in July. Further histological examination of the ovaries of
female H. menoda confirmed this finding as the GSI values
increased with increasing histological changes. Fecundity
studies revealed that H. menoda is highly fecund fish and
varies in relation to length and body weight of the fish.
Knowledge of reproductive biology of H. menoda has
application in the management and assessment of the stock
in open water bodies and in the development of artificial seed
production techniques for commercial aquaculture.
7.
Brewer, S.K., C.F. Rabeni and D.M. Papoulias, 2008. Comparing
histology and gonadosomatic index for determining
spawning condition of small-bodied riverine fishes.
Ecol. Freshwater Fish, 17: 54-58.
8.
King,
M.,
1995.
Fisheries
Biology,
Assessment
and
Management. John Wiley and Sons, New York, USA.,
ISBN-13: 9780852382233, Pages: 341.
9.
Sarker, P.K., H.K. Pal, M.M. Rahman and M.M. Rahman, 2002.
Observation on the fecundity and gonado-somatic index of
Mystus gulio in brackishwater of Bangladesh. Online J. Biol.
Sci., 2: 235-237.
46
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
22. Erkmen, B. and S.G. Kirankaya, 2016. A preliminary histological
study on ovarium development in mirror carp and scaled carp
(Cyprinus carpio L., 1758) introduced into Gelingullu
Reservoir, Turkey. J. Aquacult. Eng. Fish. Res., 2: 185-192.
23. Milton, J., A.A. Bhat, M.A. Haniffa, S.A. Hussain and
I.A. Rather et al., 2018. Ovarian development and histological
observations of threatened dwarf snakehead fish, Channa
gachua (Hamilton, 1822). Saudi J. Biol. Sci., 25: 149-153.
24. Jega, I.S., M.I. Miah, M.M. Haque, M. Shahjahan, Z.F. Ahmed
and K. Fatema, 2017. Sex ratio, length-weight relationships
and seasonal variations in condition factor of menoda catfish
Hemibagrus menoda (Hamilton, 1822) of the Kangsha river
in Bangladesh. Int. J. Fish. Aquatic Stud., 5: 49-54.
25. Rahman, A.K.A., 2005. Freshwater fishes of Bangladesh.
2nd Edn., Zoological Society of Bangladesh, Dhaka,
Bangladesh, ISBN-13: 9789843221803, Pages: 394.
26. Hossain, M.S., 2013. An Illustrated Guide to Fishes of Noakhali.
Centre for Coast, Climate and Community, Chittagong,
Bangladesh, Pages: 276.
27. Norton, V.M., K.B. Davis and H. Nishimura, 1976. A technique
for sexing channel catfish. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc., 105: 460-462.
28. Nandikeswari, R., M. Sambasivam and V. Anandan, 2014.
Estimation of fecundity and gonadosomatic index of Terapon
jarbua from Pondicherry Coast, India. Int. J. Nutr. Food Eng.,
8: 61-65.
29. Akter, H., M.R. Islam and M.B. Hossain, 2012. Fecundity and
Gonadosomatic Index (GSI) of Corsula, Rhinomugil corsula
Hamilton, 1822 (Family: Mugilidae) from the lower Meghna
river Estuary, Bangladesh. Global Vet., 9: 129-132.
30. Islam, M.A., M. Begum, H.K. Pal and M.J. Alam, 2008. Studies
on the gonadosomatic index and fecundity of Mystus gulio
(Ham.). Progr. Agric., 19: 161-166.
31. Jacob, E., 2013. Studies on the captive breeding and
reproductive biology of two indigenous ornamental fishes of
the Western Ghats. Ph.D. Thesis, Mahatma Gandhi University,
Kottayam, India.
32. Smalas, A., P.A. Amundsen and R. Knudsen, 2017. The
trade-off between fecundity and egg size in a polymorphic
population of Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus (L.)) in
Skogsfjordvatn, subarctic Norway. Ecol. Evol., 7: 2018-2024.
33. Roy, K. and D.K. Mandal, 2015. Maturity stages of ovary of a
minor carp, Labeo bata (Hamilton-Buchanon, 1822).
Int. J. Fish. Aquat. Stud., 2: 19-24.
34. Adebiyi, F.A., 2013. The sex ratio, gonadosomatic index,
stages of gonadal development and fecundity of Sompat
grunt, Pomadasys jubelini (Cuvier, 1830). Pak. J. Zool.,
45: 41-46.
35. Al Mahmud, N., H.M.H. Rahman, G.M. Mostakim, M.G.Q. Khan,
M. Shahjahan, N.S. Lucky and M.S. Islam, 2016. Cyclic
variations of gonad development of an air-breathing fish,
Channa striata in the lentic and lotic environments.
Fisher. Aquat. Sci., Vol. 19. 10.1186/s41240-016-0005-0.
10. Lawson, E.O., 2011. Length-weight relationships and
fecundity estimates in mudskipper, Periophthalmus papilio
(Bloch and Schneider 1801) caught from the mangrove
swamps of Lagos Lagoon, Nigeria. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci.,
6: 264-271.
11. Kjesbu, O.S., 2009. Applied Fish Reproductive Biology:
Contribution of Individual Reproductive Potential to
Recruitment
and
Fisheries
Management.
In:
Fish
Reproductive Biology: Implications for Assessment and
Management, Jakobsen, T., M.J. Fogarty, B.A. Megrey and
E. Moksness (Eds.). Wiley-Blackwell Scientific Publications,
Oxford, UK., pp: 293-332.
12. Vicentini, R.N. and F.G. Araujo, 2003. Sex ratio and size
structure of Micropogonias furnieri (Desmarest, 1823)
(Perciformes, Sciaenidae) in Sepetiba Bay, Rio de Janeiro,
Brazil. Braz. J. Biol., 63: 559-566.
13. Mahmood, K., Z. Ayub, M. Moazzam and G. Siddiqui, 2012.
Length-weight relationship and condition factor of Ilisha
melastoma (Clupeiformes: Pristigasteridae) off Pakistan.
Pak. J. Zool., 44: 71-77.
14. Mansouri-Chorehi, M., H. Mousavi-Sabet,
M.
Sattari,
A. Nasrollahzadeh and A. Hedayati, 2016. Age, sex ratio,
spawning season and fecundity of Alburnoides samiii
(Pisces: Cyprinidae), from Sefidroud river (the Southwestern
Caspian sea basin). Biharean Biol., 10: 93-97.
15. Kiran, B.R., 2015. Study of Gonado-somatic index of cyprinid
fish, Salmostoma untrahi (Day) from Bhadra Reservoir,
Karnataka. Int. J. Res. Environ. Sci., 1: 6-10.
16. Siddiquee, A., H. Rashid, M. Ariful Islam, K.K.U. Ahmed and
M. Shahjahan, 2015. Reproductive biology of great snakehead
Channa marulius from Sylhet Basin in the North East
Bangladesh. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 10: 294-299.
17. Solomon, S.G., V.O. Ayuba, M.A. Tahir and V.T. Okomoda,
2017. Gonad somatic index and feeding habit of selected fish
species of lake Kalgwaiin Jigawa State, Nigeria. Fisher.
Oceanogr., Vol. 4. 10.19080/OFOAJ.2017.04.555631.
18. Karmakar, P. and S.P. Biswas, 2014. Reproductive biology of
Tetraodon cutcutia (Pisces: Tetraodontidae) from Meleng
River in Jorhat District, Assam. Int. J. Sci. Technol., 2: 23-28.
19. Hossain, M.Y., M.M. Rahman and E.M. Abdallah, 2012.
Relationships between body size, weight, condition and
fecundity
of
the
threatened
fish
Puntius
ticto
(Hamilton, 1822) in the Ganges River, Northwestern
Bangladesh. Sains Malays., 41: 803-814.
20. Bailung, B. and B. Biswas, 2017. Spawning biology and
induced breeding of freshwater catfish Mystus dibrugarensis:
An approach to conservation. BioRxiv. 10.1101/229377.
21. Shalloof, K.A.S. and H.M.M. Salama, 2008. Investigations on
some aspects of reproductive biology in Oreochromis
niloticus (Linnaeus, 1757) inhabited Abu-Zabal Lake, Egypt.
Global Vet., 2: 351-359.
47
J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 13 (1): 39-48, 2018
36. Gupta, S. and S. Banerjee, 2013. Studies on reproductive
biology of Mystus tengara (Ham.-Buch., 1822), a freshwater
catfish of West Bengal, India. Int. J. Aquat. Biol.,
1: 175-184.
37. Khan, S., M.S. Hossain and M.M. Haque, 2009. Effects of
feeding schedule on growth, production and economics of
pangasiid catfish (Pangasius hypophthalmus) and silver carp
(Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) polyculture. J. Bangladesh
Agric. Univ., 7: 175-181.
38. Amtyaz, M.A.K., M.Z. Khan and M.U.A. Hashmi, 2013. Studies
on gonadosomatic index & stages of gonadal development
of striped piggy fish, Pomadasys stridens (Forsskal, 1775)
(Family; Pomadasyidae) of Karachi Coast, Pakistan. J. Entomol.
Zool. Stud., 1: 28-31.
39. Kjesbu, O.S., P.R. Witthames, P. Solemdal and M.G. Walker,
1998. Temporal variations in the fecundity of
Arcto-Norwegian cod (Gadus morhua) in response to
natural changes in food and temperature. J. Sea Res.,
40: 303-321.
40. Witthames, P.R., M.G. Walker, M.T. Dinis and C.L. Whiting,
1995. The geographical variation in the potential annual
fecundity of Dover sole Solea solea (L.) from European
shelf waters during 1991. Netherlands J. Sea Res.,
34: 45-58.
41. Seifali, M., A. Arshad, H.R. Esmaeili, B.H. Kiabi, F.Y. Moghaddam
and N. Fardad, 2012. Fecundity and maturation of South
Caspian spirlin, Alburnoides sp.(Actinopterygii: Cypriniade)
from Iran. Iran. J. Sci. Technol. (Sci.), 36: 181-187.
42. Alam, M.M., M.K. Ahsan and S. Parween, 2012. Ovarian
development, fecundity and reproductive cycle in
Securicula gora (Hamilton, 1822). DAV Int. J. Sci., 1: 96-99.
43. Pitcher, T.J. and P.J.B. Hart, 1982. Fisheries Ecology.
Croom Helm, North, Central and South America,
ISBN-13: 9780870554056, Pages: 414.
44. Fleming, I.A. and M.R. Gross, 1990. Latitudinal clines: A
trade-off between egg number and size in Pacific salmon.
Ecology, 71: 1-11.
45. Agarwal, N.K., 2008. Fish Reproduction. APH Publishing
Corporation, New Delhi, ISBN: 9788131303573, Pages: 157.
46. Silva, J.P.C., M.R. Costa, I.D. Gomes and F.G. Araujo, 2016.
Gonadal development and fecundity of the smooth
weakfish Cynoscion leiarchus (Teleostei: Perciformes:
Sciaenidae) in tropical Brazilian bay. Zoologia, Vol. 33.
10.1590/S1984-4689zool-20160032.
47. Chakraborty, B.K., S.A. Azad, B. Barman and A.M.O. Faruque,
2013. Fecundity and gonado somatic index of Gangetic mud
eel, Monopterus cuchia (Hamilton, 1822). Bangladesh J. Zool.,
41: 165-172.
48